Pin
This authentic shoo fly pie recipe brings the rich, molasses filled tradition of Pennsylvania Dutch country right to your kitchen in just one hour. Featuring a sticky sweet molasses filling and a signature crumb topping, this Pennsylvania Dutch dessert delivers comforting flavors, perfect for family gatherings or holiday celebrations when you want a nostalgic treat fast.
I first discovered shoo fly pie after a memorable trip to Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, where the tradition is alive and well in Amish bakeries. Locals shared the pie’s fun backstory, explaining how bakers had to literally shoo away flies drawn to the fragrant molasses filling as it cooled. Ever since, my family frequently requests this unique pie whenever we crave something beyond the typical apple or pecan pies, and I love sharing the story behind its name every time we bake it together.
Gather Your Ingredients
- All purpose flour for crust and topping: Key for a sturdy base and tender crumb use unbleached for best results, and gluten free 1 to 1 flour works as a substitute if needed.
- Kosher salt: Balances sweetness and brightens flavor choose fine grain for better distribution in dough and crumbs.
- White sugar: A pinch in the crust enhances browning and adds a subtle complexity, but can be swapped for coconut sugar for a slight twist.
- Cold unsalted butter: Essential for flaky pie crust and crumbly topping keep it refrigerated until using and substitute vegan butter if desired.
- Water: Just enough to bind crust dough use ice cold for maximum flakiness, and add slowly so dough doesn’t become tough.
- Packed dark brown sugar: Provides rich caramel flavor to the topping use light brown sugar for a milder result if needed.
- Ground cinnamon and nutmeg: Classic warm spices for depth and aroma use freshly ground for the boldest impact; substitute pumpkin pie spice for variation.
- Molasses: The heart of shoo fly pie for true authenticity choose robust unsulfured molasses; light molasses yields a softer flavor if preferred.
- Hot water for filling: Helps dissolve molasses and activates baking soda, making for a smooth, pourable filling.
- Baking soda: Reacts with molasses for a light but stable texture ensure it’s fresh for the best rise and consistency.
How to Make Authentic Shoo Fly Pie
- Prepare the pie crust:
- Combine flour, salt, and sugar in a food processor and pulse to blend. Add cold butter cubes, pulsing until the mixture forms pea sized pieces for a flaky texture. Gradually add water, one tablespoon at a time, pulsing just until dough starts to come together and holds when pressed. If too dry, add a bit more water but avoid overmixing so the crust remains light.
- Form and chill the dough:
- Shape dough into a disk about one inch thick on a lightly floured surface, wrap tightly in plastic, and chill in the refrigerator at least 30 minutes or up to overnight. The cold rest relaxes gluten and allows butter to firm up, resulting in a perfectly flaky base after baking.
- Roll and prepare the crust:
- Let dough soften slightly at room temperature for five minutes, then roll into a twelve inch circle about one eighth inch thick. Transfer to a nine inch pie plate, trim excess dough with a half inch overhang, fold under, and crimp edges for structural support. Refrigerate again while you make the filling and topping for consistent texture and minimal shrinkage.
- Make the crumb topping:
- Combine flour, brown sugar, cinnamon, nutmeg, and salt in a bowl. Cut cold butter into small cubes and work in with a pastry cutter or fingertips until it forms coarse crumbs with visible pea sized pieces. Proper crumb size ensures even baking and a crunchy top.
- Mix the filling:
- Preheat oven to 375°F. Whisk molasses with hot water in a large bowl until thoroughly blended, then add baking soda. Mixture will foam lightly. Stir in about one third of the crumb topping to create the classic wet bottom texture of authentic shoo fly pie.
- Assemble the pie:
- Pour molasses filling into the chilled pie crust. Evenly sprinkle remaining crumb topping across the surface, covering filling completely to lock in moisture and prevent over browning.
- Bake to perfection:
- Place pie on the center oven rack. Bake at 375°F for 15 minutes, then lower temperature to 350°F and bake 15 to 20 minutes more. Pie is done when filling is just set with a slight jiggle in the center and the topping is golden brown. The residual heat will finish setting the pie as it cools.
- Cool completely:
- Transfer baked pie to a wire rack and cool a minimum of two hours. Allowing it to cool completely is crucial for proper filling set and fullest flavor development before slicing and serving.
The search for the ideal shoo fly pie led me to historic recipes and regional debates over wet bottom versus dry bottom styles. Pennsylvania Dutch bakers once made this comforting treat in winter when fruit pies were not an option, relying on molasses and pantry staples for year round sweetness. Sharing a slice at family gatherings always sparks curiosity and conversation around its origins and flavor profile.
Smart Swaps and Variations
If you want to personalize your authentic shoo fly pie, try adding a quarter cup cocoa powder to the crumb mix for a chocolate version, or boost spice notes with extra cinnamon, ginger, or ground cloves. For a dry bottom pie, simply mix more crumb topping into the filling so the layers blend and bake into a cake like consistency. Experiment with different molasses varieties for subtle changes in depth, or add a splash of bourbon to the filling for an adult twist and deeper flavor.
How to Store and Reheat Shoo Fly Pie
Keep your shoo fly pie loosely covered with a cake dome or foil at room temperature for up to two days for best texture. For longer storage, cover the entire pie tightly and refrigerate up to five days to maintain freshness; the molasses flavor will continue to deepen. For serving, allow refrigerated slices to come to room temperature for thirty minutes, or microwave individual slices ten to fifteen seconds for a gently warmed treat, preserving both crust and crumb texture.
What to Serve with Shoo Fly Pie
Shoo fly pie shines with classic accompaniments that balance its rich sweetness. Serve it with freshly whipped cream for creamy texture, or a scoop of vanilla ice cream for cold contrast. Enjoy a slice alongside hot black coffee or strong tea to cut through the sticky molasses filling, or drizzle on a touch of apple cider syrup for a fruity finish reminiscent of Pennsylvania Dutch kitchens.
Nutritional Benefits
While shoo fly pie is an indulgent dessert, molasses offers nutritional benefits by providing iron, calcium, potassium, and antioxidants. Compared to refined sugars, molasses has a lower glycemic index, resulting in a slower blood sugar rise. With its natural minerals and no artificial additives, this pie can be a comforting treat that delivers more than just sweetness.
Recipe Success Tips
If your pie turns out too runny, it may need a few extra minutes in the oven, or you might have used too much water in the filling. Prevent crumb topping from sinking by allowing the filling to cool just slightly before sprinkling on crumbs rather than as soon as it’s mixed. To avoid soggy crust, consider blind baking the crust for 10 minutes, and always let pies cool fully to achieve the cleanest, neatest slices.
Every bite of this authentic shoo fly pie connects you to generations of Pennsylvania Dutch baking with its signature molasses richness and crumbly topping. Bake it for your next gathering and enjoy a dessert that’s both unique and deeply comforting.
Common Questions About This Recipe
- → What is shoo fly pie made of?
Shoo fly pie is traditionally made with a molasses filling, a crumbly topping of flour, butter, and brown sugar, and a flaky pie crust seasoned with cinnamon and nutmeg.
- → How do you get the best crumb topping for shoo fly pie?
Use cold butter and pulse it with flour and sugar until the mixture forms pea-sized crumbs. Sprinkle this evenly over the molasses filling before baking.
- → Why is it called shoo fly pie?
The pie's sweet molasses filling is said to attract flies, making bakers shoo them away as it cools. Its name is a playful nod to that tradition.
- → How is shoo fly pie typically served?
It is usually served at room temperature, but some enjoy it slightly warm, sometimes with a dollop of whipped cream or a scoop of vanilla ice cream on the side.
- → Can I make shoo fly pie ahead of time?
Yes, you can prepare it a day ahead. Let it cool completely, then cover and store at room temperature. The flavors will meld and improve overnight.