Save This
When I need a sure thing at dinnertime, this Amish Country Casserole never lets me down. Creamy noodles and tasty ground beef come together for a meal that folks can’t wait to dig into. It’s just flat-out cozy and fills you up after a busy day.
I stumbled on this one back when hosting my in-laws took over an entire week. Everyone loved it. My mother-in-law even asked for it and now cooks it all the time at her house, too.
Hearty Ingredients
- Cheddar cheese brings the gooey pockets inside and some crunchy goodness up top. Bold, sharp cheddar really pops.
- Ground beef builds the meal’s heartiness and makes every forkful filling. An 80/20 mix keeps things juicy.
- Egg noodles are sturdy and wide, so they soak up sauce without getting soggy.
- Potato chips or breadcrumbs add that must-have crunchy layer that’s just plain fun against all that creaminess.
- Onion is what makes the flavor sing right from the start. Yellow ones are sweet and mellow.
- Cream of chicken soup softens everything out and keeps the dish from being too rich.
- Frozen peas (if you want) bring color and a touch of sweetness and make this more of a one-bowl dinner.
- Garlic powder gives everything a smooth, gentle garlic taste without taking over.
- Cream of mushroom soup turns up the savory flavor with minimal effort.
- Sour cream zings everything up, making things tangy and super creamy if you go for full-fat.
Simple Steps
- Bake It
- Pop the dish into your oven (set at 350°F) and leave uncovered for about 30–35 minutes. You want it bubbly around the edges with a golden, cheesy top.
- Add Crunch on Top
- Spoon all your mixed-up casserole into the pan, spread it out, then layer on the last of the cheese and those crunchy chips or breadcrumbs.
- Mix in Cheddar
- Fold a cup of shredded cheddar right into everything. That way you get pockets of melty cheese in every bite—not just on top.
- Combine Everything
- Dump your beef and onions into the sauce mix and give it all a good stir. Fold in noodles and peas (if using) so everything’s coated.
- Make It Creamy
- In a big bowl, mix both soups, sour cream, and any seasonings together until smooth. This becomes your creamy sauce.
- Cook the Onion With Beef
- Add chopped onion to your drained beef on the stove, cook a couple more minutes until the onions are see-through but not brown—they’ll sweeten up the whole dish.
- Brown Up the Beef
- Grab a large skillet, cook the ground beef til there’s no pink left, break it up as it cooks. Drain the fat so it doesn't get greasy.
- Get Ready to Cook
- Set your oven to 350°F and grease your baking dish. This keeps things from sticking and helps that top layer get toasty without burning the cheese.
Save This
I love how these simple egg noodles turn so satisfying in this dish. My grandma always swore plain noodles were key for comfort food, and this casserole never proves her wrong. They suck up the perfect amount of sauce but still keep their bite—just like Sunday dinners at her place.
Easy Prep Ahead
This dish is great if you know you’ll need it later. Put everything together right up to baking, wrap tight with foil, and keep in your fridge for up to 2 days. Before cooking, let it sit out for half an hour. Then bake, just adding about 10 more minutes to the oven time. Letting it rest overnight makes the flavors even better.
Switch It Up
You can change things up easily. If you’re out of egg noodles, grab rotini or penne. Swap ground turkey for beef for a lighter option, or go meatless with sautéed mushrooms instead of beef. Try pepper jack instead of cheddar if you want a little kick, or toss in some smoked paprika for a different twist.
Serving Ideas
This meal works all on its own, but I like to put a simple green salad with tangy dressing beside it. In fall, I serve it up with applesauce or spiced apples for a classic Amish touch. Sometimes I’ll set out extra sour cream and let everyone add a spoonful on top for an extra hit of creamy tang.
Classic Amish Roots
This dish reflects why I love Amish cooking—simple stuff that comes together to feed lots of people. It’s hearty and filling, using what you’ve got. Technically, it’s a modern twist—the original would have used a homemade white sauce instead of canned soups—but it’s got that spirit of bringing everyone together around the table.
Common Queries
- → Can I swap out the ground beef?
Absolutely! Try using ground turkey, chicken, or even a plant-based option to change things up.
- → Do I really need to include peas?
Not at all. You can skip them or sub with veggies like diced carrots or green beans.
- → What can I use instead of potato chips on top?
Breadcrumbs are a perfect substitute. Crushed crackers or even more cheese could work too!
- → How long will leftovers stay fresh?
Leftovers should be kept in the fridge in a tight container for 3 to 4 days. Reheat with the microwave or oven for the best taste.
- → Could I prep this in advance?
Yep! You can put it together and leave it in the fridge for up to a full day. Wait to add the topping until you're ready to bake.
- → What sides pair nicely with this meal?
A crisp salad, steamed greens, or some crunchy garlic bread would make a nice combo with this casserole.