Save This
Whenever I've got a packed schedule and want something cozy, this Amish Country Casserole is my favorite to throw together. Creamy noodles and flavorful ground beef mean everyone comes running when dinner hits the table.
I stumbled on this one during a wild week with my in-laws. Mom-in-law was hooked, snagged my method on her way out, and it’s now her go-to meal too.
Inviting Ingredients
- Garlic powder gives the whole thing a background garlic vibe, nice and mellow
- Cheddar cheese melts inside each bite, while the top gets extra cheesy and crispy, full-flavored if you go sharp
- Frozen peas are optional but add fun green color and a little sweet pop
- Onion brings all those background flavors together, especially yellow for a sweet hit
- Cream of chicken soup blends right in with the mushroom soup, helping to keep things rich but not too heavy
- Potato chips or breadcrumbs (your call) deliver that brilliant crunchy finish on top
- Sour cream keeps things tangy and balances out the heavier stuff; full-fat tastes richest
- Egg noodles are the sturdy base here and soak up just enough sauce
- Cream of mushroom soup gives you that deep, savory kick with almost zero work
- Ground beef is what makes this filling and satisfying — 80/20 is my pick for ultimate flavor
Simple How-To Steps
- Bake to Golden
- Pop it in the oven uncovered at 350°F for around 30 to 35 minutes. Take it out once the edges bubble and the top has that tasty brown crust. You’ll love the mix of creamy and crunchy.
- Add Chips and Cheese
- Spread the whole blend into your baking dish. Scatter the rest of the cheese on top, then finish with a layer of crushed chips or breadcrumbs.
- Fold in Cheese
- Toss in a cup of shredded cheddar and mix it in gently — this way there are gooey cheesy bits tucked all through the casserole.
- Mix it All Up
- Stir your beef-and-onion mixture into that creamy sauce. Toss in the cooked egg noodles and peas now if you want them. Make sure everything’s covered nicely in sauce.
- Whip Up the Creamy Mix
- In a big bowl, stir together both soups, the sour cream, and all seasonings until totally smooth. This coats and flavors the noodles in every bite.
- Sauté Onion
- Now add in the chopped onion with the browned beef and keep it on the stove for a couple minutes. Onions should turn see-through but not brown — you just want them soft and sweeter.
- Cook Beef
- Brown up your ground beef in a decent-sized skillet over medium heat, breaking it up real fine as it cooks. When it’s all cooked through, drain off any grease so it doesn’t turn out too heavy.
- Prep Your Oven
- Heat oven up to 350°F and coat your dish with some butter or a quick shot of spray. That way you don’t wind up scraping out stuck noodles later.
Save This
The way egg noodles turn out in this is pure magic. My grandma always said the right noodles make comfort food, and this proves her point. They pull in just the right amount of sauce and stay firm enough, every time I eat this it feels like those cozy Sunday dinners at her house.
Easy Make-Ahead
This dish is awesome for planning ahead. Get it all layered up (except for baking), cover up tight, and stick it in the fridge for up to two days. Take it out about half an hour before you want to bake it—that helps it bake evenly—then just follow the regular baking time, adding a few extra minutes if it’s super cold. It actually tastes even better the next day!
Best Swaps
You can really make this your own. No egg noodles? Any twisty or short pasta like rotini or penne does the trick. Swap ground turkey for a lighter take or go meatless by using a bunch of mushrooms. Want to shake it up? Try pepper jack cheese or a pinch of smoked paprika for an extra level of flavor.
Tasty Ways to Serve
This is great straight from the pan, but if you want a side, a crisp salad with vinaigrette keeps things fresh. In fall, I’m a fan of serving it with spiced apples or even applesauce—very traditional. For something a little extra, a dollop of sour cream at the table never hurts.
Timeless Amish Traditions
This dish really shows the simple, practical side of Amish-inspired cooking. They’re all about filling food for big families, using easy-to-find stuff and making it taste amazing. While it’s a new-school take with canned soups instead of old-fashioned white sauce, it nails the spirit of making something comforting that feeds a crowd.
Common Queries
- → Can I swap the ground beef for something else?
Of course! Try ground turkey, chicken, or even plant-based options to mix things up.
- → Do I need to include the peas?
Not at all! Skip them or trade for veggies like chopped carrots or green beans.
- → What can I use instead of potato chips on top?
Bread crumbs make a great alternative. Crushed crackers or extra cheese work well too!
- → How long do leftovers stay good?
Store extras in a sealed container in the fridge for up to 3-4 days. Warm them up in the microwave or oven for the best taste.
- → Can I prep this in advance?
Sure! Make it ahead and refrigerate for up to a day before baking. Just add the topping right before it goes into the oven.
- → What pairs nicely with this dish?
A crisp salad, some roasted vegetables, or buttery garlic bread would be delicious sides.