Save This
This macaroni salad bursts with creamy richness and plenty of crunch, bringing serious flavor to any backyard cookout or picnic. Inspired by Guy Fieri’s big, bold approach to classics, every bite delivers tangy zip and a satisfying texture on the fork. It is pure comfort tossed in a bowl and everyone comes back for seconds.
I always whip up this macaroni salad for big family gatherings – after the first time I made it, my uncle asked for the recipe and now it is on repeat every summer. The tangy sauce wins everyone over.
Ingredients
- Elbow macaroni: Pasta shape holds the dressing perfectly and is easy to eat in a crowd. Look for bronze-cut pasta if possible for texture that grabs more of the creamy sauce.
- Shredded carrots: Fresh sweetness balances the creamy dressing. Use crisp firm carrots for shredding.
- Diced red bell pepper: Adds bright pop of color and natural sweetness. Look for shiny skin and no soft spots.
- Diced celery: Classic crunch that makes every forkful satisfying. Choose crisp stalks with plenty of leaves for flavor.
- Chopped red onion: Brings gentle edge and color in every bite. Try soaking in water for a few minutes if you need a milder flavor.
- Mayonnaise: The creamy backbone of the salad. Use full-fat for the richest taste.
- Sour cream: Adds tangy depth and an extra luscious finish. Choose fresh and thick for the best body.
- Yellow mustard: Brings classic tang and a bit of classic deli flavor. Stick with yellow for authentic taste.
- Apple cider vinegar: Lifts and balances the richness with gentle acidity. Go for unfiltered for a hint of fruit.
- Garlic powder: Aromatic boost that ties all the flavors together. Freshness matters so check the best-by date.
- Paprika: Gives subtle color and a little smoky warmth. Sweet or smoked both work depending on your mood.
- Salt and pepper: Finish and adjust seasoning to your liking. Taste as you go to balance.
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Cook and Cool Pasta:
- Boil a large pot of salted water and cook elbow macaroni until just tender. Watch the clock closely for true al dente. Rinse under cold water immediately to stop cooking and cool completely. This keeps the noodles from getting mushy.
- Chop and Prep Veggies:
- Finely dice carrots, bell pepper, celery, and onion so every bite gets a mix. Set them aside in a big bowl ready for tossing. This adds appealing color and crunch.
- Mix Dressing:
- Whisk together mayonnaise, sour cream, yellow mustard, apple cider vinegar, garlic powder, paprika, a generous pinch of salt, and black pepper. The dressing should be thick, creamy, and boldly seasoned. Taste it now so you can adjust if needed.
- Combine and Toss:
- Add cooled pasta over the chopped veggies then pour the entire bowl of dressing on top. Use a big spoon or spatula and mix until everything is evenly coated. It should look glossy and colorful. Make sure all the pasta is fully covered.
- Chill and Serve:
- Cover and refrigerate at least one hour. This rest time lets the flavors meld and the salad cools to the perfect picnic temperature. Give it one last stir and maybe a sprinkle of extra pepper just before serving.
Save This
I love how the creamy tangy sauce brings all the vegetables together. It is always a hit with kids and adults alike. My own favorite ingredient is the apple cider vinegar – it makes the flavors pop and keeps the salad from getting too heavy. We always serve this at family BBQs and there is never a spoonful left.
Storage Tips
Store your macaroni salad tightly covered in the refrigerator. It will stay fresh and flavorful for up to three days. If it starts to look a little dry, just stir in an extra spoonful of mayonnaise before serving. I have even enjoyed leftovers straight from the container for a quick lunch.
Ingredient Substitutions
No sour cream? Just use a little extra mayonnaise or some plain Greek yogurt for tang. If you want more heat, swap regular paprika for smoked or add a diced jalapeño. Missing red bell pepper? Try orange or yellow instead for the same crunch and sweetness.
Serving Suggestions
Macaroni salad is the classic side to barbecue ribs, burgers, grilled chicken, or even fried fish. I have served it at potlucks alongside corn on the cob and watermelon wedges and it fits right in. For a pretty presentation, scatter chives or parsley over the top just before serving.
Cultural Context
This style of creamy macaroni salad likely started in American diners and backyard picnics decades ago and it is still a nostalgic favorite today. Inspired by Guy Fieri’s diner flair, this version leans on bold ingredients and over-the-top flavor memories that bring everyone back for another bite.
Common Queries
- → What makes this macaroni salad different?
It combines a creamy base with a tangy, bold flavor inspired by Guy Fieri—perfectly balanced with crunchy veggies.
- → Can I prepare macaroni salad in advance?
Absolutely. Chill it for at least one hour to let the flavors blend, or make it a day ahead for maximum taste.
- → What pasta works best?
Classic elbow macaroni is ideal for holding the creamy dressing and blending well with the veggies.
- → How do I store leftovers?
Store in an airtight container in the fridge for up to three days for best freshness and texture.
- → Can I add extra ingredients?
Feel free to toss in diced pickles, chopped herbs, or even a pinch of cayenne for more heat and flavor.