Save This
This hearty Caprese Stuffed Portobello Mushrooms recipe transforms simple ingredients into an impressive Italian-inspired dish. The combination of melted mozzarella, sweet tomatoes, and earthy mushrooms creates a satisfying meal that feels indulgent while remaining low carb and nutrient-dense.
I first made these stuffed portobellos when hosting an impromptu dinner party, and they've become my go-to when I want something that feels special without hours in the kitchen. Even my mushroom-skeptical friends request these regularly.
Ingredients
- Large Portobello mushrooms: Carefully cleaned and dried for the perfect meaty base
- Fresh mozzarella cheese balls: Sliced thinly for that classic melt and stretch
- Grape or cherry tomatoes: Bringing bright acidity and natural sweetness
- Fresh basil leaves: Adding that distinctive aromatic finish
- Butter and garlic: Creating a rich foundation of flavor
- Balsamic glaze: For that perfect sweet tangy finish
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Prepare the Mushrooms:
- Clean the portobellos thoroughly and dry them with paper towels using gentle pressure to remove excess moisture. This crucial step prevents soggy mushrooms and ensures they roast properly.
- Create the Garlic Butter:
- Melt butter in a small saucepan with crushed garlic and chopped parsley until fragrant. The butter should become golden and infused with garlic aroma but not brown. This flavored butter base elevates the entire dish.
- Prepare the Mushrooms:
- Brush the garlic butter mixture generously on both sides of each mushroom, placing them cap side down first. Ensure each mushroom is evenly coated for maximum flavor absorption.
- Add the Filling:
- Layer mozzarella slices and thinly sliced tomatoes inside each mushroom cap. Arrange them attractively as they will be visible in the final presentation. The cheese should cover most of the mushroom cavity.
- Broil to Perfection:
- Place under the broiler for approximately 8 minutes, watching carefully until the cheese melts and develops golden spots. The mushrooms should soften while maintaining their shape.
- Finish with Garnishes:
- Top the hot mushrooms with fresh basil and drizzle with balsamic glaze. The heat will release the basil's oils and aromas while the glaze adds a beautiful finishing touch.
Save This
The balsamic glaze truly transforms this dish from good to memorable. I once served these at a family gathering without it and while delicious, adding that final drizzle brought gasps of appreciation from everyone at the table. The sweet tanginess balances the richness perfectly.
Perfect Pairing Suggestions
These stuffed mushrooms work beautifully alongside a simple arugula salad dressed with lemon and olive oil. The peppery greens complement the richness of the mushrooms without competing for attention. For a heartier meal, serve with crusty whole grain bread to soak up the delicious garlic butter and balsamic glaze.
Make Ahead Options
You can prepare these mushrooms up to the broiling stage several hours ahead. Simply clean and stuff the mushrooms, cover tightly with plastic wrap, and refrigerate. When ready to serve, brush with the garlic butter and broil for 9 to 10 minutes instead of 8, as the chilled mushrooms will need slightly longer to heat through.
Ingredient Substitutions
If fresh mozzarella is unavailable, good quality shredded mozzarella works well though the texture will differ slightly. For a dairy free version, try a cashew based cheese alternative that melts similarly. The portobellos themselves can be substituted with large field mushrooms if needed, though cooking time may need adjustment based on their size.
Common Queries
- → How do I prevent the mushrooms from becoming watery?
Thoroughly dry each portobello with paper towels, using one sheet per mushroom. Gently press to squeeze out excess liquid. If mushrooms aren't properly dried, they'll release too much moisture during cooking, making the dish soggy.
- → Can I make the balsamic glaze ahead of time?
Yes! The homemade balsamic glaze can be prepared several days in advance and stored in an airtight container in the refrigerator. Warm slightly before using, or use at room temperature. You can also substitute store-bought balsamic glaze.
- → How can I tell when the mushrooms are done cooking?
The mushrooms are ready when the cheese has melted completely and turned golden brown on top, which takes about 8 minutes under the broiler. The mushroom caps should also be tender when pierced with a fork.
- → Are these suitable for a keto diet?
Yes, these stuffed mushrooms are keto-friendly with only 13g of carbohydrates per serving. To reduce carbs further, skip the sugar in the balsamic glaze or use a sugar-free alternative.
- → Can I prepare these mushrooms in advance?
You can prepare the components ahead of time: clean and dry the mushrooms, slice the cheese and tomatoes, and make the balsamic glaze. However, for best results, assemble and broil just before serving to ensure a fresh-tasting dish with properly melted cheese.
- → What can I serve with these stuffed mushrooms?
These versatile mushrooms pair wonderfully with a simple green salad, roasted vegetables, or crusty bread for a complete meal. They also work as elegant appetizers for dinner parties or as part of an Italian-themed antipasto spread.