Save This
Sink your teeth into this cheesy cowboy butter chicken linguine. Juicy chicken pieces and soft linguine noodles get dressed up in a buttery, herby sauce with a kick. It's a seriously cozy meal but super doable on busy nights.
This dish happened one night when I wanted to fix a crowd-pleasing dinner with hardly any notice. My friends wiped their plates clean and begged for more. Now if I want to impress and still keep it chill, this is what I make. Ordinary nights feel just a little fancy with it.
Savory Ingredients
- Lemon juice perks up the dish and brightens things up with a little zing
- Dijon mustard—don’t skip it, it gives the whole thing a surprise boost of flavor without tasting like mustard
- Chicken broth loosens up the sauce while making it rich
- Linguine pasta—these flat noodles are perfect for grabbing onto the sauce
- Boneless skinless chicken breasts—chop these into small bits so they cook evenly and stay juicy
- Unsalted butter so you can decide exactly how salty your dish gets
- Olive oil and butter—using both helps everything taste great and makes cooking easier
- Garlic powder & onion powder—super reliable, won’t burn like fresh stuff in a hot pan
- Smoked paprika throws in a deep, smoky layer regular paprika just can’t
- Cayenne pepper optional, but brings that cowboy fire
- Parmesan cheese—grate it yourself for melty goodness and fresh flavor
- Heavy cream the secret for that thick, dreamy texture
- Fresh parsley—chopped up and tossed on last for color and a fresher finish
Tasty Step-by-Step
- Serve and Top It Off
- Dish the pasta onto warm plates and give it a twirl with your tongs for that restaurant look. Pour extra chicken and sauce right over the top. Sprinkle on more parsley and a handful of parmesan if you’re feeling cheesy. Eat straight away so you don’t miss out on the gooey sauce and texture.
- Bring It All Together
- Slide the chicken back into the skillet with all that lovely sauce and give it a gentle mix. Drop in the drained noodles and toss it all till the noodles are slick and glossy. Last, add in the grated parmesan to melt, some chopped parsley, and a squeeze of lemon juice. Too thick? A splash or two of that saved pasta water sorts it out.
- Simmer Cowboy Butter Sauce
- Drop the heat down to medium on that skillet, then let the butter melt all the way. Stir in cream, broth, and a hit of Dijon, whisking as you go. Want extra pep? Sprinkle in red pepper flakes. Let the sauce simmer a couple minutes. You’re looking for it to thicken up and coat a spoon, but you should still be able to pour it.
- Sizzle The Chicken
- Dice up your chicken and toss it with all those spices and a hefty pinch of salt and pepper. Warm a pan with some oil, toss the chicken in one layer so they can brown. Leave them alone a few minutes, then flip—about 3 to 4 minutes per side. They’re done when they hit 165°F. Take them out and put a loose bit of foil on top to keep in the heat.
- Pasta Time
- Fill a big pot with water and salt it well. Let it come to a hard boil, then drop in your linguine. Cook till it’s just right—usually around 9 to 11 minutes. Scoot off about a quarter cup of the starchy water for later, then drain your pasta. Skip rinsing—you want that starch on the noodles for extra clingy sauce.
Save This
Dijon’s a game changer here. The first time my kid watched me add it, she pulled a face, but when she tried a bite, she was hooked! It just gives the dish this mellow tang and makes everything pop without ever shouting “mustard.”
Awesome Pasta Water Trick
Don’t forget to save some pasta water—seriously, it’s like sauce magic. The natural starch makes your sauce super silky so it hugs every noodle. If things ever look weird or feel thin, splash in a bit and stir. It’ll get the sauce smooth and glossy. Great tip for leftovers, too—no more greasy, split sauces when you heat it up again.
Switch It Up
This cowboy butter combo is crazy flexible. Lighten it up by swapping in half and half instead of full cream. Want greens? Toss in baby spinach, cherry tomatoes, or mushrooms near the end. Looking to mix things up even more? Try shrimp or even pop in some cooked bacon for smokiness. There are tons of ways to make it yours.
Leftovers Made Easy
Pop leftovers in a lidded container and they’ll keep great for 2-3 days in the fridge. Warm it slowly on medium-low and add a bit of milk or cream so everything stays smooth. Flavors usually get even deeper by the next day. You can even prep the butter mixture ahead and keep it in the fridge—just let it get back to room temp before you use it here.
Save This
Common Queries
- → What’s cowboy butter made of?
It’s a mix of butter packed with fresh herbs, spices, and often a citrusy element. In this meal, it becomes a silky sauce for chicken and pasta.
- → Can I swap chicken for something else?
For sure! Shrimp makes it seafood-friendly, and tofu works great for a vegetarian spin. Both pair wonderfully with the sauce.
- → How do I get the sauce extra creamy?
Don’t drain all the pasta water! Save some to mix into the sauce for that smooth finish you get at restaurants.
- → Can I tone down the heat?
Of course! Leaving out the cayenne and red pepper flakes will keep it flavorful without the spice.
- → What veggies go well with this dish?
Spinach or cherry tomatoes are perfect. Toss them in during the final minute to add color and nutrients.